
Last weekend I purchased a few apples from the farmers market in Union Square, and had a couple of large ones left this weekend. Usually when I have a bunch of apples on hand I’ll make apple crisp, but I wanted to do something different. Considering I only had two apples, I couldn’t make a full apple pie, so I decided to try making single-serving pies. I had no idea if it would turn out okay, but hooray – they’re great!

I’ve decided I want to expand my apple horizon, and try some other varieties. I’ve only really been acquainted with the standard grocery store apples – Golden Delicious, Granny Smith, and Fuji, among others. It’s high time that I branch out (no pun intended).
The apples that I purchased last weekend are called Idared, or Ida Red. They are a cross between the Jonathan and Wagener varieties, and have a mostly sweet flavor with just a hint of tart. They are supposed to be great when baked, so I forged ahead with making these little pies.
Mini Apple Pies
For the crust:
- 1 cup white all-purpose flour
- 6 Tbsp. butter I used Soy Garden
- 2 Tbsp. cold water
For the filling:
- 2 large baking apples, peeled and sliced into small pieces
- 1/3 cup sugar I used turbinado
- 1/8 cup white all-purpose flour
- 1/2 tsp. cinnamon
- 1/2 tsp. nutmeg
- dash of salt
In a medium-sized bowl put 1 cup of flour. Cut in the butter with a fork or pastry blender/cutter until the mixture has small lumps. Sprinkle the cold water over the flour and butter and stir together until the dough pulls together and away from the sides of the bowl. If the mixture doesn’t seem to be doing this you can add another tablespoon of water. Roll the dough into a ball, wrap it in plastic wrap, then place it in the refrigerator for 20 or 30 minutes so it becomes firm. This will make it easier to work with.
Mix together all of the filling ingredients except for the peeled and sliced apples. After they have been mixed add in the apples (or vice versa depending on your bowl situation) and stir until the dry ingredients have been well incorporated with your apples. Set aside.
Preheat your oven to 345 degrees Fahrenheit.
Take your dough out of the refrigerator and split into two. On a floured surface roll out the dough until it is thin (not too thin otherwise it will tear).
Use a small bowl as a guide and slice around the bowl like so:

Then take the circle of dough and press it into your muffin pan:

Score the bottom of the dough with a fork a few times. Fill the dough with the apple mixture so that it comes over the top of the pan (when the apples are baking they will loose a lot of their water and sink down).

Cut the excess dough, but don’t do what I did in the following picture. I should have left more dough, so I’d say leave a centimeter of dough on the outside.

Now cut a smaller circle of dough and put it on top of your pie. Pinch the top dough together with the bottom dough (the centimeter part). Score the top with a knife. If you get really creative you can cut little leaves out of your scraps of dough and place those on top. They may fall off, though, so you’ll need to make sure they are secure (gently mashing the ends into the top pie dough).
Continue doing this process until you’ve run out of enough dough or apple filling. There is bound to be leftovers of both so you can just bake the remaining apples in a separate pan, make a pie with no top pie crust, or make a small apple crisp after all.

Place the muffin pan in the oven, and place a sheet of aluminum foil on the rack below to catch any liquid that may fall from the pan. Bake for about 35 minutes, and check to make sure the apple pies are done.
Once they are done take them out of the oven and let them sit for about 15 or 20 minutes so they get cool enough to handle. It’s not easy taking these little pies out of the pan so you may have to be careful while coaxing them out with a knife.
Now you can serve with some vegan clotted cream (I’d suggest doing more cream cheese than butter) or just eat the little things plain.

I’m not that good at making pies but these turned out so well. It’s probably a more intensive process to make a bunch of little pies than one big pie, but they are so cute and it’s such a good idea for serving to guests. Of course, it’s great for making just for yourself. It’s also a good way to not feel guilty about eating a whole pie (or two or three) by yourself.

Related posts:

{ 21 comments… read them below or add one }
I found a cool trick for making pies look like the shiny store bought ones….just take a little corn syrup and mix with a couple drops hot water until thinned slightly. When you pull the pie out of the oven, lightly brush the mixture over the top of the pie crust to glaze it, then sprinkle some extra course sugar crystals on top. You’ll need to put it back in the oven for about 3 minutes, to set the syrup so its not sticky.
The extra 3 minutes won’t burn the crust or overcook the apples, just set the glaze!
Thanks for your mini recipe. I was nervous about making pies smaller but this worked perfectly!
I really want to try this recipe! But I was wondering, is it hard to take out these mini-pies from the muffin pan? Would using a cupcake liner be easier to take out the mini-pies?
Hi Sherry! If your filling is going to bubble out of the mini pies it might be a little more challenging getting the pies out. You can try doing what you are thinking, or I would try coating the inside of the pan and the top, just around each hole, a tiny bit of vegan butter or vegetable oil. This may help!
I made these but instead of using the muffin pan I cut my pie dough into squares and wrapped up the apple slices so that they looked like a small apple dumpling. My husband loved them! Just the right size. I plan to try it using peaches next time. Thanks for sharing.
I just made these and am pretty dang excited.
Reading your blog, the idea struck me the same way it struck you which is awesome. How random that I, also, had a hankering for apple pie with only two apples in the fridge.
Also, the fact that these turned out is a huge leap for me. I’m a professional cake decorator but was TERRIFIED of pie crust. I have now overcome that fear!
Next on that list is yeast and bread. :D
I used brown sugar and it was a delightfully gooey filling. So good. And oh so happy.
These are soo cuuute!
I just made them the other day for my friend’s birthday, and everyone loved them (: The only trouble was actually taking them OUT of the muffin tin, because the sugar in the filling oozed out and stuck the pie to the pan :/ But overall, they turned out great!
Great recipe; thanks!
Will this be enough dough for 24 pies using a 12 muffin pan? Also there be alot of extras? And will it be the dough or apple? Im making this tommorow so im just wondering.
Nici – this makes about 6 mini apple pies using a standard sized muffin tin. There shouldn’t be a lot of extra dough or apples, as you’ll be using the dough for both the bottom and top crusts, and the apples will reduce down as they are baking so you’ll need to overfill each muffin tin. I hope this helps!
I made these for a party this weekend and they turned out great! Thanks so much!
I just made these and they came out perfect! Such a great recipe, and the ingredients are things I already had around.
Hello! I just found these today and they looked too cute and simple to not make right away! I used Gala apples and really liked the apple/spice mix, it tasty strangely gingerbread-y, and I did half white sugar and half dark brown sugar. The dough was simple and tasty.
Unfortunately I made me dough too thick when making the little guys (I only had enough dough for 4), so the taste was too doughey. Oh well, lesson for next time I make these, which will hopefully be soon!
Beautiful post! Makes me sorry I don’t eat cooked/baked any more…but not enough to try them. I know you and your DH enjoyed them and that’s enough.
Try Ambrosia apples if you are fortunate to run across them. I got some organic ones and they are delicious! They’re a sweet variety so they might not be as good for apple pie. They’re great for eating out of hand, though.
Absolutely adorable! I’m not a fan of leftovers so making individual mini pies is ideal. Also, I simply like “small food”, just so cute!
What cute little pies! I made a similar thing a month or so ago, called them “cup pies” — like “cupcakes.” I love the leaf decorations on the tops of yours!
I’m going to try making them. How many mini pies does the recipe make?
If I remember correctly, I believe that this was six mini pies. I didn’t really have a goal when I set out to make these, but I think I was able to fill the entire muffin pan which has molds for six regular sized muffins.
I was just wondering how many mini pies does this recipe make?
Samantha – These are the cutest mini pies ever. A quick tip for those making them. I went through 3 test rounds and finally nailed them. The problem… I was leaving too much dough on the cupcake pan and thus when I went to pop them out of the pan, the top came off and the bottom stayed in the pan. The fix (THIS IS IMPORTANT) make sure to cut that bottom crust bigger and the top crust smaller. I folded the bottom crust into the top crust to make a rustic rolled edge. And again make sure the crust diameter does not exceed the side of the muffin tin by too much or you risk “popping the top” and not the whole pie out of the tin. I used Trader Joe’s frozen pie dough and made 9 mini pies with two pie crusts. I would recommend a mix of granny smith & mcintosh (from America’s Test Kitchen recipe). Delicious!
Thanks so much for the recipe! I’ve never made pie from scratch, but with your help, my girlfriend and I made the most amazing Apple Cup-pies in celebration of Pi Day (3/14).
I suggest doubling or even tripling the recipe. Only makes about five or six mini pies. But by far, this is the most delicious mini pie recipe, and a beautiful tutorial so us fumbly-fingers know exactly what to do. ;)
I enjoyed making these little suckers. I should make them again and vary the filling – blueberries, cherries, chocolate (oh my that would be good)…